Art Is Art

By Bill Hendricks

Recently, Instagram labeled a photograph of one of my drawings as AI-generated. The drawing was mine, created with pen and ink. I had asked ChatGPT to help correct the color in the photograph because the original was too gray and flat.

The first correction wasn’t quite right. I asked for changes to the color and darker areas, reviewed the results, and approved the image. Later, I made my own correction using Affinity Photo and replaced the photograph on Instagram.

The experience got me thinking about AI, artistic authorship, and how we judge creative work.

A tool is a tool.

I’ve spent much of my life watching technology change how creative work gets done. When I studied design, we learned to specify type for professional typesetters. Then came the Macintosh, desktop publishing, Photoshop, and other tools that transformed the printing and design industries.

Some jobs disappeared, new possibilities opened up, and artists and designers adapted.

Now we have AI.

What bothers me isn’t the idea of acknowledging AI involvement. It’s how that involvement is described and why visual art seems to receive so much attention.

If Instagram had labeled my photograph AI-assisted color correction, I wouldn’t have objected. That’s what happened. But AI-generated suggests something quite different. It implies that AI created the drawing itself.

It didn’t.

And that raises a larger question. Why are we so concerned about identifying AI involvement in visual art?

What about poetry, literature, music, and other creative work? AI is being used in all of them. If we’re going to require disclosure, shouldn’t the same standards apply across the arts?

For that matter, artists have never been expected to explain every technique they use. A painting might be identified as oil on canvas, but that tells us very little about how it was made. We don’t normally ask artists to account for every brush, medium, correction, or revision.

Why should AI be different?

Then there’s the question of where AI gets its information and images. People point out that AI systems are trained on enormous collections of existing work, including copyrighted material.

That’s a legitimate concern, particularly when it comes to permission and compensation.

But artists have always looked at other artists for inspiration. I certainly have.

I’ve traveled to Mexico because I’m fascinated by the use of color and symbolism in Mexican art. I’ve studied Paul Klee and his wonderful arrangements of color and geometric shapes. Warhol, Peter Max, Vasarely, and M. C. Escher have all influenced how I think about images.

I look at their work. I learn from it. Sometimes I borrow an idea about color, composition, or structure and take it somewhere else.

That’s part of being an artist.

Of course, there’s a difference between an artist studying another artist’s work and a company training an AI system on millions of images without necessarily obtaining permission. Those questions deserve serious consideration.

But I don’t believe that every image involving AI should automatically be considered a copy or somehow less original.

I also think we’re overlooking something important about the creative process. Someone working with AI may spend considerable time describing what they want, selecting colors, adjusting compositions, reviewing results, and deciding when the work is finished.

Those are aesthetic decisions. They’re part of making art.

Does that mean everything created with AI is good art?

Of course not.

There’s plenty of schlock out there, and there always has been. Some of it is made with paintbrushes, some with cameras, some with computers, and now some with AI.

I’ve seen wonderful work made with the simplest materials and some pretty awful work made with the most sophisticated equipment.

The tool doesn’t guarantee the quality of the result.

And if someone wants to buy something I think is terrible, that’s their choice. They may see something in it that I don’t. That’s part of what makes art interesting.

I’ve spent enough years making art, teaching art, and looking at art to know that we don’t all respond to the same things.

Nor should we.

I’m not suggesting that artists should misrepresent their work. If someone claims a work was entirely handmade when it wasn’t, that’s a different matter.

But I don’t believe artists should have to provide a complete explanation of their creative process simply because they used AI.

And if someone doesn’t like the fact that an artist used AI?

Tough noogies.

They don’t have to like it. They don’t have to buy it. They can move on to something else.

What matters to me is the work itself, the choices behind it, and the experience it offers the viewer.

Technology will continue to change. It always has. Artists will continue to experiment, adapt, and find new ways of expressing themselves.

And audiences will continue to decide what they value.

A tool is a tool. Art is art.

It Wasn’t Always “Glory Days”

Abstract pen-and-ink drawing by Bill Hendricks featuring intricate blue and black geometric patterns, flowing organic shapes, circles, and decorative borders.
Intricate Blue and Black-10092026 Hendricks©2026

I was walking today, thinking about how things have happened in my life. So much wasn’t planned. Things came along, I stepped into them, and before I knew it, I was doing it for better or worse.

Looking back, I’m amazed at how things worked out. But they weren’t always glory days. I didn’t always know where I was going or whether things would work out.

I kept doing it while making course corrections along the way. Now I’m spending more time thinking about what comes next, but I’m already doing what I want to do.

I’ve been noticing something similar in my drawings. Working with pen and ink makes me slow down. Every line matters. I have to look at what’s happening, think about what I’m doing, and decide where the next line goes.

It challenges me.

Maybe that’s why being present came to mind today. Whether I’m drawing or walking, there’s something about paying attention to what’s happening around me. I guess that is called presence.

Bill Hendricks

Confidence and Trust

I have confidence in sunshine,
I have confidence in rain.
I have confidence that spring will come again!
Besides which, you see, I have confidence in me!

— “I Have Confidence,” The Sound of Music
Rodgers & Hammerstein

When I was teaching, my students used to get a kick out of the fact that every once in a while I would break into song.

One of my favorites was I Have Confidence from The Sound of Music.

I’ve been thinking about that song lately. I’ve also been thinking about confidence, trust, and résumés.

A résumé can list what I’ve done. It can remind me of exhibitions, teaching, projects, and accomplishments. But confidence doesn’t come from a list of what I’ve already done.

It comes from trusting what I can do next.

I’ve been working on a new series of small drawings and paintings, and I’m pleased to say that some of them will be going to New York in December for Collective Z’s Small Works show.

I’m excited to be showing with Collective Z again. It’s a wonderful small gallery, and I’ve really enjoyed working with Alex Z. Wang.

Will every piece I make be the best piece I’ve ever made? Probably not.

That’s not really the point.

Whatever comes out of that process, it will be the best of me.

Bill Hendricks

 

Three small abstract pen-and-ink drawings with geometric lines, symbols, and machine-like forms arranged on an artist’s worktable.
Three works in progress from the Small Works series, 2026. Pen and ink on paper.

Collective Z is a contemporary gallery and project space on Broome Street in New York, dedicated to artists working in states of transition, tension, and becoming.

— Collective Z

Marsha P.: When the Past Becomes Present

I find myself reminiscing about the past more often these days.

I think about Christopher Street and the wonderful life that was lived there. I think about the friends I made, and the friends who became family, during one of the most intense periods in LGBTQ+ history—the AIDS epidemic.

So many of those friends are gone now.

But I still think about them. I remember them. And I think about the wonderful life I have had, and the life I am still having, and how much fun it would have been to share some of this life with them.

Maybe that has something to do with how Marsha P. came into being.

The drawing did not begin as Marsha P. Johnson.

I know that.

It began as a very abstract sort of image. I was working with shapes and lines without any intention of making a portrait.

Then I began to see something.

First I saw the smile.

At this point, I was exploring how to tint underneath the drawing—putting color down and then bringing areas back.

As I worked, I began to see the eyes.

And all along there was a certain joy in the drawing that kept coming through.

I continued drawing, painting, changing things, covering things, uncovering things. The more I worked, the more something from my own history seemed to be coming forward.

My past became present.

Marsha was part of the world I remember.

I don’t mean that Marsha and I were close friends. We weren’t.

She was someone who passed through my life.

But she was a character on Christopher Street, just as I was a character on Christopher Street—working in a gallery among lots of other characters I loved dearly.

There was something about seeing her emerge from this drawing that gave me a way of becoming involved with that world again.

Not simply remembering it.

Participating in it.

For a little while, the distance between then and now became smaller.

The finished work became Marsha P.

For me, it carries more than the image of one person. It carries something of Christopher Street, of friendship, of loss, of survival, and of the extraordinary joy that existed alongside some very difficult years.

Maybe that is why the joy in the drawing matters so much to me.

The work later traveled to New York, where it was exhibited during Pride Month. The original Marsha P. is now available through Collective Z Gallery on Artsy.

But when I look at it, that isn’t what I think about first.

I think about the people.

I think about the life we lived.

Sometimes, while making a drawing, the past finds its way back into the room.


Currently at Collective Z

Collective Z is currently presenting Second Nature, bringing together painters Gwen Yip and Spencer Patrick. Their work considers the spaces New Yorkers move through—from the public world of subway platforms to the private interiors where people retreat.

Second Nature is on view through August 29, 2026, at Collective Z, 325 Broome Street, New York.

Learn more about the exhibition.

Looking Back, Looking Forward: A Follow-Up to “Patterns Emerge”

Maps, patterns, and finding my way

Mixed media drawing framed like a symbolic icon, featuring a stylized central form resembling a letter B or figure, directional arrows, geometric symbols, ribbon-like lines, and soft blue shading — suggesting identity, energy, and becoming.
Metaphysical Being — mixed media on paper, 2026.

Maps, patterns, and finding my way

Metaphysical Being — mixed media on paper, 2026.

Lately I’ve been thinking about how I got here.

I was born in 1953.

In 1969, I remember hearing about Stonewall late one night on KDWB radio. They were interviewing Jack Baker.

I was sixteen years old.

For the first time, I realized there were others. I wasn’t alone.

Looking back now, I realize that moment wasn’t just about being gay. It was the beginning of a lifelong search for direction—for understanding how people find their place in the world and how we make sense of lives that don’t always fit the expected path.

I’ve spent much of my life looking for paths.

Sometimes those paths appeared as maps. Sometimes as diagrams. Sometimes as outlines, websites, or decision trees. Often they appeared simply as ways of organizing what I could see—and finding relationships among things that did not, at first, seem connected.

As a teacher, I spent years making outlines, building websites, drawing wireframes, and thinking in mind maps. I taught Gestalt theory—the idea that our minds naturally seek relationships and organize visual information into meaningful wholes.

Being dyslexic, I think I was already doing that long before I knew there was a name for it.

I’ve often described myself as someone who sees patterns. And I still believe that’s true.

But during one of my daily walks, another thought quietly surfaced.

Maybe what has fascinated me all these years hasn’t been patterns themselves.

Maybe it’s been finding my way.

Patterns are useful because they reveal possible paths. Maps matter because they help us navigate. Even a labyrinth has a pattern—but its purpose isn’t the pattern itself. Its purpose is to help us travel and find ourselves.

That realization feels surprisingly important.

When I look back over my life—from hearing Jack Baker on the radio… to teaching students how we make sense of the world… to designing websites… to creating art… to exploring identity, community, and spirit—I don’t see disconnected experiences anymore.

I see one long journey.

The maps changed.

The questions changed.

The medium changed.

But the journey remained remarkably consistent.

Lately I’ve started calling some of my drawings Decision Trees.

At first I thought they were simply abstract compositions.

Now I wonder if they’re visual journals.

They resemble the maps, outlines, webs, and structures I have used throughout my life—not because I planned them that way, but because they’ve always been part of how I think.

As an artist, I don’t begin with answers.

I begin with curiosity.


Here’s a bit of what KDWB sounded like around that time:
KDWB—Channel 63, January 3, 1970.

Related post: This reflection continues the ideas I began exploring in Looking Back, Looking Forward, where I considered how patterns can help us find our way.